A tower house on a bluff in West Dallas

The lot is a warehouse parcel on West Commerce Street. Its back edge is the top of a seventy-foot bluff, reached from a cul-de-sac. From there the ground falls north toward the Trinity, and downtown stands on the horizon to the east.

The building is a small tower at the brow of the bluff: 28 by 24 feet, five levels, entered from the street by a fifty-foot bridge. A work space sits at the bottom, dug into the slope. Above it are two lofts for two bachelors, stacked and interlocked: a smaller one with the best corner, and a larger one with the roof.

From the cul-de-sac it is a blank industrial object, closed and a little forbidding, giving nothing away until you are on the bridge. Toward the river and the city it opens. It is one plain block with the view corner carved out.

This is a sketch, made for the pleasure of it. Nothing here has been surveyed, priced or permitted.

Diagrams

In the order the design was worked out. Click one to open it full size.

1Site

The lot, its contours and where the views are. The land hides nothing of downtown; trees and roofs are unchecked.

site_plan
1_site/site_plan.svg
view
1_site/view.svg

2Placement

The tower at the brow of the bluff, 50 ft in, reached by a level bridge. These still show the first, plain stacking inside; the outside is the same size.

axon
2_placement/axon.svg
section
2_placement/section.svg

3Stacking

Three ways to stack two lofts and a work space, then the one chosen: unequal lofts interlocked around a stair. Not yet squared with the wish for one room per floor.

interlock
3_stacking/interlock.svg
variants
3_stacking/variants.svg

4Plans

The bridge level only: a landing, two doors, loft A.

plan_bridge_level
4_plans/plan_bridge_level.svg

5Massing

Five ways to cut one plain block. Chosen: the carved corner, with plain punched openings elsewhere.

massing
5_massing/massing.svg

6Ground

How the tower meets the slope. Chosen: dug in, possibly deeper than first drawn.

ground
6_ground/ground.svg

7Air

For fun: the closed south wall as a Persian wind catcher.

air
7_air/air.svg

Precedents

Tower house at 2570 W Commerce St, Dallas: two lofts over a work space in a small tower at the brow of a bluff, entered by a bridge from a hilltop cul-de-sac, in an industrial district. Grouped by the question each one helps with. DESIGN.md has what was decided.

The site and the bridge

Tower House, Portland — Waechter Architecture (2013). The nearest thing to this site. Steep lot entered from the uphill street; a 25 ft steel bridge lands on the third of four floors. ~600 sf footprint, one main room per floor, service spaces packed into the perimeter. Black corrugated steel with rounded corners. Built up rather than out specifically to keep the foundation small on the slope. Liked: the subtractive geometry, openings and the entry cut out of one plain block; and one room per floor with the services in the wall. ArchDaily · Dezeen · Architectural Record

Closed and intimidating from outside

The tower should read as industrial and a little forbidding from the cul-de-sac, disguised until you are on the bridge, and probably still then.

Cien House, Concepción — Pezo von Ellrichshausen (2011). The architects' own house and studio: a seven-storey poured-concrete tower on a podium, on a hill over the city. Square windows of different sizes punched through a rough monolith; a spiral stair runs up the tower. Work below, living above, in one block that gives nothing away. ArchDaily · Architectural Record · Dezeen

Casa Alférez, Mexico — Ludwig Godefroy (2023). A concrete tower in a forest that goes up rather than out because of the terrain, on an 81 m² footprint. Nearly blank walls below, openings saved for the top. The architect calls it a small castle, a protected mini tower. Dezeen · Wallpaper

Mountain Cabin, Laterns, Austria — Marte.Marte (2011). A four-storey poured-concrete tower on a steep hillside, 43 m² footprint, 87 m² of floor. Rough on the outside, smooth inside. Square openings of different sizes are punched through the shell, and one whole level is cut away as an open terrace: subtraction from a monolith, like Waechter, in a heavier material. ArchDaily · Dezeen · Archiweb

Delta Shelter, Washington — Olson Kundig (2005). A 1,000 sf steel box on stilts with a 200 sf footprint. Four 10 × 18 ft steel shutters slide over the glass, all moved at once by a hand wheel, so the cabin closes up completely into a blank steel block. A way to be shut and menacing from outside and open inside. ArchDaily · Dwell

Art Stable, Seattle — Olson Kundig (2010). Five live/work lofts stacked over ground-floor commercial space in a former industrial neighborhood. Giant hand-cranked hinged windows on the street side, a vertical stack of "art doors" with a hoist on the alley side. Not liked from outside; kept for the interiors and for the hoist and big doors on a work level. Architizer · Archello

Power House, 3321 Armstrong Ave, Dallas — Cunningham Architects (1988). 1920s Dallas Power & Light substation turned into a three-story house. Kept the brick shell, the traveling crane and the chain fall; added steel, glass and industrial stairs. The Dallas reference for living inside industrial fabric without softening it. SAH Archipedia · Doug Newby

One room per floor

Tower House, Tokyo — Takamitsu Azuma (1966). Raw concrete on a 20 m² plot: six levels around a central stair, about 65 m² in all. The board marks run horizontally and show the floors stacking. The original tiny urban tower. Wikipedia · ArchEyes · Socks

4x4 House, Kobe — Tadao Ando (2003). A concrete tower on a 4 m square footprint, four storeys. The top floor is a cube pushed 1 m off the axis toward the sea, with the living room and a full-height window in it: the whole building is a stalk for one room with a view. Wikipedia · ArchEyes

Small House, Tokyo — Unemori Architects (2010). 4 × 4 m, 9 m high, four levels and a roof terrace, on a 34 m² site. Thin floors and a spiral stair at the centre; huge openings with timber shutters. ArchDaily · Dezeen

Small House, Tokyo — Kazuyo Sejima (2000). One use per floor on a 60 m² lot, each floor given the footprint its use needs, so the outline leans in and out as it rises. Architecture Tokyo

Tower House, Leander TX — Andersson-Wise (2008). Two bedrooms stacked on floors one and two, and an open, shaded terrace on top, 30 ft up, as the "living room." A habitable roof as the best room in the building. Andersson-Wise · Dezeen

Two units in one volume

Double House, Utrecht — MVRDV with Bjarne Mastenbroek (1997). Two families, unequal shares, one block. The party wall meanders in section: each house pushes rooms into the other's volume, taking space on one floor and giving it back on the next, so the smaller house still gets a big living room and a view of the park. The houses were worked out in section, not plan. MVRDV · Wikipedia · Arquitectura Viva

House & Atelier Bow-Wow, Tokyo (2005). Work on the lower two floors, living on the upper two, on split levels so the stair is the building and no floor is fully separated from the next. Liked for the interior; not where this building is headed. ArchDaily · Archiweb

Vertical Alley, Tokyo — No. 555. Narrow tower, two floors of work under two floors of home, industrial materials. Remodelista

Air, and what the top is for

Persian wind catchers (badgir), Yazd, Iran. Towers built onto houses to cool them with no machinery. Openings at the top face the wind and push air down through the rooms; in still air the tower works as a chimney and draws hot air up and out. Thick walls, and water in channels below, add to the effect. Yazd has about 700; the one at Dowlatabad garden is about 34 m tall. For us: a tall, closed, thick-walled tower in Dallas heat already has the parts. The stair shaft or the service wall could be the wind tower, and the top of the building gets a job beyond a parapet. Wikipedia · Atlas Obscura · Ferrovial

Not looked up yet (from memory)

Cut

Dropped as not teaching us anything; their photos are in photos/cut/.